« Wherein M1EK defends teenagers | Main | What a shock »

Gee, thanks

Austin Bike Blog author Elliott talks about a big meeting with a bunch of folks I usually like and then paraphrases in part 2 from his conversation with the guest of honor:

I also asked him what we could be doing to make Austin better for its citizens. He suggested dedicated bus lanes and bikeways on our busiest transit corridors would do a lot to get people out of their cars (We discuss the route of Capital Metro’s #1 bus which passes within walking distance of 40% of Austin’s employers.)

Gee, I wonder if there was anybody making the point, say, in 2003-2004, that passing this idiotic commuter rail plan dooms us to basically never getting reserved-guideway transit service on the #1 route along which essentially all the dense employment centers are located? How many of the notables at this meeting (*) spoke up then?

None. M1EK had to do it all his lonesome, even giving up his position on the UTC to do it while everybody else who knew this was the wrong plan shamelessly kept their mouth shut to preserve their access to decision-makers.

Thanks, guys. Thanks a hell of a lot.

(* - like most of these meetings, I, of course, since I have a real job in a real office, couldn't attend).

Our options going forward are extremely limited. We can't politically or even pragmatically justify taking lanes on Lamar and Guadalupe now, since we can't continue northwest with frequent-enough LRT service to get enough people on the trains to make up for the lost car/bus capacity. The CAMPO TWG plan is foundering, but may, twenty years from now, eventually lead to a conversation about rail on Guadalupe, where it belongs now, always has, and always will.

In the meantime, pay attention: those who advocate going along with suburban or other non-Austin interests in the hopes that they'll take care of us later have a long record of failure to overcome. Everybody knows the #1 corridor is where most transit activity is now and will be in the future. What are we doing about it? Jack Squat.

Update: Elliott's response was a flavor of the common "why are you such a downer?", to which I just let fly this analogy-ridden response:

Using my favorite roadtrip analogy:

1. You don’t get the car to New York by insisting that, although we’re heading west on I-10 and approaching the outskirts of El Paso, that everything’s fine and we’re on target for New York - although we may need to go even farther west to get there.

2. You also don’t get the car to New York by letting the guy who read the map wrong the first time continue to think that he read it correctly and should therefore continue to navigate. You give the map to the guy who said you’re supposed to be going northeast rather than west.

3. You also don’t get that car to your destination by downplaying how far off course you went, or you might end up out of gas before you even get back to square one (Austin).

4. Finally, you don’t get your goal by telling the people you’re meeting in New York that you’re still on schedule, even though you’re now, at best, going to be two days late.

(1 = more investment in the Red Line, 2 = not identifying that commuter rail is the problem rather than the solution, 3 = not identifying that commuter rail prevents the 2000 LRT plan from being built, 4 = downplaying obstacles to getting rail on Guadalupe in the real world now that it can’t continue northwest along 2000 alignment).

PS: Crappy formatting care of the fact that I still haven't bothered to learn CSS. You're lucky I didn't do all this with tables, so quit yer yappin'.

This entry was posted in the following categories: 2008 Light Rail , Austin , Don't Hurt Us Mr. Krusee, We'll Do Whatever You Want , I Told You So , PS: I am not a crackpot , Texas Republicans Hate Cities , Transit in Austin , Transportation

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://mdahmus.monkeysystems.com/cgi-m1ek/MT/mt-tb.cgi/512

Comments

Coming back from PDX, I've truly realized how much Austin transportation sucks. Portland not only has better bus service, along with their amazing light rail system, there are bike lanes EVERYWHERE. Austin's claim to being a "bike-city" are a joke.

I'm moving to Oregon. Heck, even went to a small town on the coast, and their downtown had proper bike lanes.

M1Ke, let it go. It's 2009, not 2004!

Wouldacouldashoulda is really childish.

Anyway, Obama will certainly give us a nice rail system if just pray to him sincerely.

Jim,

"Wouldacouldashoulda is really childish.

Anyway, Obama will certainly give us a nice rail system if just pray to him sincerely."

You could not have come up with a better unintentional demonstration of irony if you tried.

Read the roadtrip analogy again, since you clearly don't get it.

Jim,

"Wouldacouldashoulda is really childish.

Anyway, Obama will certainly give us a nice rail system if just pray to him sincerely."

You could not have come up with a better unintentional demonstration of irony if you tried.

Read the roadtrip analogy again, since you clearly don't get it.

I still don't get it. There is only one transit route in Austin that is worth putting light rail on, the current #1 bus route. From memory, i believe the #1 route served about 5 times as more riders as any other Cap Metro route. No other rail is really worth building. No other rail is a game changer the way this route is. Metro Austin already voted for this plan, which would undoubtedly pass if the vote was held again today.

Where is the political leadership on this????

Post a comment