Comments: Cap Metro operating subsidies - then and now
Comments
Mr. Cortez asked me to adjust Metrorail for the relatively low capital outlay.
Well, here is a comparison of data with the Hiawatha (now Blue) Line in Minneapolis - this is relevant to me as I visit the Twin Cities fairly often. To me - both as a user and as an amateur analyst - the winner here is obvious.
Blue Line
Capital cost to state/local: $291m (1)
Boardings/day: 31,400 in 2010 (peak was 35,500 in Summer 2008) (1, 2)
Operating loss/rider: $1.45 (3)
MetroRail
Capital cost to state/local: "$120-200m" according to Ben Wear (4)
Mr. Cortez asked me to adjust Metrorail for the relatively low capital outlay.
Well, here is a comparison of data with the Hiawatha (now Blue) Line in Minneapolis - this is relevant to me as I visit the Twin Cities fairly often. To me - both as a user and as an amateur analyst - the winner here is obvious.
Blue Line
Capital cost to state/local: $291m (1)
Boardings/day: 31,400 in 2010 (peak was 35,500 in Summer 2008) (1, 2)
Operating loss/rider: $1.45 (3)
MetroRail
Capital cost to state/local: "$120-200m" according to Ben Wear (4)
Boardings/day: 1700-1800 (4)
Operating loss/rider: $33.25 (5)
Sources:
1. http://www.startribune.com/local/west/123722719.html
2. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hiawatha_Line
3. http://hizeph400.blogspot.com/2011/07/lets-eliminate-transfers-or-1-fare-plan.html
4. http://www.austin360.com/this-is-austin/traffic-may-be-bad-but-austin-increasing-other-1632896.html?printArticle=y
5. http://www.dahmus.org/blogimg/2011redlineopsubsidies1.png
Posted by: Seanbrown8
|
August 19, 2011 04:33 PM